I just watched this video from Just Have a Think. Dave Borlace makes some good points about competition for land use, particularly between agriculture and solar PV installations.
One concern is that, as demand for land increases, solar installations could eventually begin displacing high-quality agricultural land — although we are not there yet. He draws an interesting parallel with biofuel production, where increased demand for agricultural land contributed to higher food prices.
One of the solutions he discusses is mixed land use, or agrivoltaics, where raised PV panels are installed over land that continues to be used for agriculture. This seems particularly promising for livestock farming: animals can continue grazing underneath and between the panels, while the shade can reduce heat stress and moisture loss and may even improve grazing conditions in some environments.
This made me think of South Africa.
Ideally, much of our future utility-scale solar development should be concentrated in the country’s semi-arid livestock-farming regions. Large parts of the Northern Cape and the drier interior of the Western Cape have abundant sunshine, relatively low rainfall and vast areas used for extensive grazing rather than intensive crop production. Raised agrivoltaics could allow these farms to produce both electricity and livestock from essentially the same land.
For over two decades, it boggled my mind why there weren’t enormous developments like this all over the Karoo.
The issue that eventually unboggled my mind was when I heard an energy specialist exlainp the design of the grid on some radio show. Apologies for not noting who it was, or even when. I simply can’t recall.
South Africa’s electricity network was not designed around the geography of renewable energy. It was designed around coal. Large power stations were concentrated close to the country’s coalfields, particularly in Mpumalanga, and the transmission network was consequently built to move enormous amounts of electricity from those relatively concentrated generation areas to the country’s major population and industrial centres.
This creates an awkward transitional problem.
In the long term, it makes sense to expand and reorient the transmission grid towards the country’s best solar resources, including the vast semi-arid grazing regions of the Northern Cape and Karoo. Doing that will require enormous investment in long-distance transmission infrastructure, potentially including High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) lines.
But we don’t have to wait for that grid to be completed before building solar.
The first generation of large-scale solar installations can take advantage of the current transmission infrastructure. That means building more generation in and around the existing coal-generation regions, particularly Mpumalanga, where grid connections are already concentrated.
The difficulty is that this is also generally better-watered and more productive agricultural land than the semi-arid regions where I would ultimately prefer to see much of the country’s solar generation located.
This is where agrivoltaics becomes particularly attractive.
Instead of converting cattle-grazing land in Mpumalanga into land used exclusively for electricity generation, raised solar installations could allow us to use the same hectares for both. Cattle continue grazing underneath and between the panels while the farm simultaneously produces electricity. In other words, agrivoltaics can help reduce the land-use conflict during the period in which our renewable-energy geography is still constrained by a grid inherited from the coal era.
Over the longer term, as South Africa builds new transmission capacity, solar development can increasingly shift towards the country’s semi-arid livestock-farming regions, where the solar resource is excellent and competition with high-value agricultural land is lower. Agrivoltaics would remain useful there too: rather than replacing extensive livestock farming, solar generation could become an additional use of the same land.
So I see this as a two-stage transition in the transmission.
In the short term, use agrivoltaics to put solar where much of the transmission capacity already exists, while preserving agricultural use of that land.
In the long term, build the transmission infrastructure needed to move electricity generation towards the places where South Africa’s geography actually gives solar its greatest comparative advantage — our vast, sunny, semi-arid grazing regions.
The limiting resource isn’t sunshine. We have an extraordinary amount of that. The challenge is gradually making the geography of our electricity grid match the geography of the energy resources that will replace coal.
